Improving Efficiency in the T&D System

Improving Efficiency in the T&D System (photo credit: ABB Inc.; High voltage direct current valve hall)

Energy Efficiency in Power System

One example of efficiency measures aimed primarily at the utilities that operate the T&D system is an initiative underway at the US Department of Energy to implement new efficiency standards for distribution transformers.

These are the grey cylinders you see perched atop utility poles in residential neighborhoods, and the metalhoused units placed on cement pads at ground level.

There are over 40 million distribution transformers in service today in the US. They are among the most ubiquitous and the most standardized pieces of electrical equipment, and for that reason make a prime target for improvements that can then be propagated across large areas.

The proposed standards will have a relatively modest impact on the efficiency of a given transformer, around 4% over current models. However, when this incremental gain is multiplied across the thousands of units operated by even a small utility, the result is impressive.

There are other initiatives at the distribution level, but if we focus our attention on the measures that have the greatest potential for improving efficiency, we inevitably must look to transmission.

There are numerous technologies that are already being applied to boost efficiency in transmission, and still more that have yet to reach full commercial implementation.

In the following sections, we explore some of these technologies:

  1. HVDC – High-Voltage Alternating Current
  2. FACTS (Flexible AC Transmission Systems) Devices
  3. Gas-Insulated Substations (GIS)
  4. Superconductors / HTS Cables
  5. Wide Area Monitoring Systems

1. HVDC – High-Voltage Alternating Current

A 350 kV ABB HVDC Light transmission system

A 350 kV ABB HVDC Light transmission system that stabilizes weak power networks in Namibia also enables power trading in the expansive region of southern Africa.


Most of the transmission lines that make up the North American transmission grid are high-voltage alternating current (HVAC) lines.

Direct current (DC) transmission offers great advantages over AC, however:

  • 25% lower line losses,
  • Two to five times the capacity of an AC line at similar voltage,
  • Ability to precisely control the flow of power.

Historically, the relatively high cost of HVDC terminal stations relegated the technology to being used only in long-haul applications like the Pacific DC Intertie, which connects the vast hydro power resources of the Columbia River with the population centers of Southern California.

With the advent of a new type of HVDC, invented by ABB and dubbed HVDC Light, the benefits of DC transmission are now being realized on much shorter distances. The Cross-Sound Cable connecting Long Island and Connecticut is one example of this technology.

Go back to Topics ↑


2. FACTS (Flexible AC Transmission Systems) Devices

ABB Flexible AC transmission systems (FACTS) installation in Canada

ABB Flexible AC transmission systems (FACTS) installation in Canada


A family of power electronics devices known as Flexible AC Transmission Systems, or FACTS, provides a variety of benefits for increasing transmission efficiency. Perhaps the most immediate is their ability to allow existing AC lines to be loaded more heavily without increasing the risk of disturbances on the system.

Actual results vary with the characteristics of each installation, but industry experience has shown FACTS devices to enhance transmission capacity by 20-40%. FACTS devices stabilize voltage, and in so doing remove some of the operational safety constraints that prevent operators from loading a given line more heavily.

In addition to the efficiency gains, these devices also deliver a clear reliability benefit.

Go back to Topics ↑


3. Gas-Insulated Substations (GIS)

World's one of the largest SF6 gas insulated switchgear installation, at Three Gorges Dam in China: ELK-3 GIS, 73 bays, 550 kV

World’s one of the largest SF6 gas insulated switchgear installation, at Three Gorges Dam in China: ELK-3 GIS, 73 bays, 550 kV


Most substations occupy large areas of land to accommodate the design requirements of the given facility.

However, each time power flows through a substation to step down the voltage, more energy is lost as the power flows through the transformers, switches and other equipment. The efficiency of the lower-voltage lines coming out of the substation is also markedly lower than their high-voltage counterparts.

If power can be transmitted at higher voltage to a substation that is closer to where the energy will be consumed, significant efficiency improvements are possible.

Gas-insulated substations essentially take all of the equipment you would find in an outdoor substation and encapsulate it inside of a metal housing. The air inside is replaced with a special inert gas, which allows all of the components to be placed much closer together without the risk of a flashover.

The result is that it is now possible to locate a substation in the basement of a building or other confined space so that the efficiency of high-voltage transmission can be exploited to the fullest extent.

Go back to Topics ↑


4. Superconductors / HTS Cables

Superconducting materials at or near liquid nitrogen temperatures have the ability to conduct electricity with near-zero resistance.

Relative power increase compare HTS cable to XLPE cable

Relative power increase compare HTS cable to XLPE cable


So-called high temperature superconducting (HTS) cables now under development, which still require some refrigeration, can carry three to five times the power of conventional cables.

The losses in HTS cables are also significantly lower than the losses in conventional lines, even when the refrigeration costs are included. A major vendor of superconducting conductors claims that the HTS cable losses are only half a percent (0.5%) of the transmitted power compared to 5-8% for traditional power cables.

Superconducting materials can also be used to replace the copper windings of transformers to reduce losses by as much as 70% compared to current designs.

Go back to Topics ↑


5. Wide Area Monitoring Systems

Wide area monitoring and operation

Wide area monitoring and operation


Much of the transmission system could feasibly be operated at a higher loading, were it not for reliability concerns. However, if operators were given the ability to monitor grid conditions more precisely and in real time, some of these constraints would be removed.

One example relates to the simple fact that when transmission lines heat up, the metal becomes pliable and the lines sag, which can cause a short circuit if they come into contact with a tree or other grounding object.

Wide area monitoring systems (WAMS) have many promising capabilities, one of which is line thermal monitoring. With this functionality, transmission operators could conceivably change the loading of transmission lines more freely by virtue of having a very clear understanding of how close a given line really is to its thermal limits.

Go back to Topics ↑


HVDC Light 3D (Video)

Cant see this video? Click here to watch it on Youtube.


Reference: ABB – Energy Efficiency in the Power Grid


author-pic

Edvard - Electrical engineer, programmer and founder of EEP. Highly specialized for design of LV high power busbar trunking (<6300A) in power substations, buildings and industry fascilities. Designing of LV/MV switchgears. Professional in AutoCAD programming and web-design. Present on Google+.



One Comment


  1. Konstantin Filyaev
    Apr 19, 2014

    Yes, semiconductor converter-based systems (including VSC) are really great in power systems states management! I think, the 6th item should be added to the list above – energy storage devices (kinetic, lithium-ion and others).

Leave a Comment

Tell us what you're thinking... we care about your opinion!
and oh, not to forget - if you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a free Gravatar!


7 − five =

FOLLOW EEP!

Subscribe to Weekly Download Updates: (free electrical software, spreadsheets and EE guides)

EEP's Android Application
Electrical Engineering Daily Dose
Daily dose of knowledge and news from
Electrical Engineering World

Advertisement

Get
PDF