AC vs. DCWhat’s this thing about AC anyway? A little history lesson might be in order. It all started when Edison built the first incandescent bulb and the power station to light it. A big disadvantage of DC electricity immediately revealed itself: you couldn’t build the power houses any further than a few blocks from where the electricity was produced.

Why? The resistance of the wire consumed a portionof the power. Houses close to thepower station had brilliant lights andthose at the furthermost reach had dimones. The last guy on the line had it bad. When someone close to the powerhouse turned on a whole bunch of lights, his would dim even further. And pity the poor farmer! He couldn’t get any power out there in the country until a few companies got smart and started manufacturing wind-electric machines.

Then along came Nikola Tesla, thefather of AC motors and generators. Ifyou make AC at any voltage, it can be transformed through use of the highly efficient transformer to any other voltage. Stepping up the voltage has the effect of stepping down the current for the same power transfer.

Why does this matter?

Power delivered to the “load” (anything which uses power) is defined as the product of Amps and Volts, or P=IV. On the other hand, line losses (the energy lost in the transmission wires) are determined by the product of Amps squared times ohms (the resistance of the wire), or P=RI2.

Note that voltage plays no part in line losses.

With AC, then, the transformer stepped up the voltage (or down, depending on the ratio of the number of windings of input and output) to hundreds of thousands of Volts. Naturally, since “power out” must equal “power in” (minus losses), the AC current decreased in the same proportion.

Thus, super-high voltage and super-low current meant very low line losses irrespective of how far you needed to send it. Of course, very high voltage is dangerous stuff for appliances, lights, and motors.

With AC, however, once you get the power to the home, farm, or shop, a second transformer (on the utility pole) would step the voltage back down for use.

The point of this historical review?

There’s nothing really “sacrosanct”about 120-volt, 60-cycle AC. It is convenient for the utilities to use because it’s the only way they have to transfer power over long distances. If your power is homegrown, you don’t have their problems, so why necessarily accept their solution?

True, after you’ve considered all the factors, you may decide that high voltage will work best for you in your situation.

SOURCE: Backwoods Home Magazine – January/February 2000

About Author //

author-pic

Edvard Csanyi

Edvard - Electrical engineer, programmer and founder of EEP. Highly specialized for design of LV high power busbar trunking (<6300A) in power substations, buildings and industry fascilities. Designing of LV/MV switchgears.Professional in AutoCAD programming and web-design.Present on

17 Comments

  1. […] energy is generated, transmitted, distributed, and utilized as alternating current (AC). However, alternating current has several distinct disadvantages. One of these is the necessity of reactive power that needs to […]

  2. […] at the interfaces between the cable and the accessory that is very different from the stress under AC voltage. A careful examination of the system is necessary prior to a DC test in order to avoid […]


  3. ankushbahale
    Aug 08, 2013

    Please give me details regarding working principle and construction of Synchroscope.

  4. […] = 60; Using AC and DC together in electrical system? There are a number of issues to using AC and DC together in the same electrical system. Briefly, they are: circuit boxes and hardware, outlets, wiring […]


  5. ervinothkumarv
    Apr 08, 2013

    If we connect the loads in parallel connection means the voltage is became constant right??? then what is the point to consider the voltage drop???? voltage stepup and stepdown only the advantage in AC


    • Edvard
      Apr 08, 2013

      Voltage drop depends on conductor length, cable factor and cable cross section.

  6. […] What’s this thing about ac any-way? A little history lesson might be in order. It all started when Edison built the first incandescent bulb and  […]

  7. […] power systems uses either 50Hz or 60Hz alternating current. Because of this, the use of an alternating current source to test insulation would appear to be the logical choice.Figure 1 – Insulation with an AC […]

  8. […] the rectifier voltage into a direct current.One, which stabilises or smoothes the pulsating DC voltage and places it at the disposal of the inverter.One, which converts the constant DC voltage of […]

  9. […] energy is generated, transmitted, distributed, and utilized as alternating current (AC). However, alternating current has several distinct disadvantages. One of these is the necessity of reactive power that needs to […]

  10. […] input powers are same and there is not any another source other than the signal (that is incoming AC voltage), Amplifier can amplify the signal voltage without reducing the output current.Transformer follows […]

  11. […] A digital multimeter is used to make various electrical measurements, such as AC and DC voltage, AC and DC current, and resistance. It is called a multimeter because it combines the functions of […]

  12. […] on Mars is one of the three main challenges for the upcoming colonisation of the red planet. The energetic potential on its turn is mainly dependent on the astrophysical characteristics of the planet. A short insight […]

  13. […] these insulators or bushings provide the proper insulation distance for normal operation voltages (AC, DC, and BIL), they do not provide sufficient distances to eliminate bridging of many animals from […]

  14. […] primary and secondary circuits.The primary is always the portion of the winding connected to the AC power source. This transformer may be used to step voltage up or down. If the primary is the total winding and […]


  15. jdgoy
    May 06, 2011

    Can you touch on HVDC transmission? It was my understanding that DC power transmission has no reactive power and therefore is highly more efficient than AC which will have a reactive component. Is this true? One drawback I read about was that DC at high voltages is much more dangerous than AC at high voltages, could you explain that as well? Thanks.

  16. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Electric Engineering, Electric Engineering. Electric Engineering said: AC Vs. DC http://t.co/Nxco9Gi #electrical #engineering #eep […]

Leave a Comment

Tell us what you're thinking... we care about your opinion!
and oh, not to forget - if you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a free Gravatar!

nine × three =

Get PDF