Condition monitoring based maintenance management of electrical equipment - Part 1

Condition monitoring based maintenance management of electrical equipment (on photo: Performing the manufacturer’s recommended maintenance and testing of a circuit breaker will extend the equipment’s useful life; photo credit: plantservices.com)

The cost of maintenance

In today’s competitive market scenario, all types of industries are under tremendous pressure to cut down their maintenance costs, as they form a significant portion of the operation costs. The industries are forced to look for different types of maintenance of the electrical equipment rather than usual preventive maintenance being carried out at a fixed interval of time.

Over the past twenty years or so, the concept of maintenance has been assuming different dimensions and changing a lot, perhaps more so than any other management discipline. The changes are due to a huge increase in the number and variety of plant equipment in the industries, which must be properly maintained.

The electrical equipment with much more complex designs require new maintenance techniques and changing views on maintenance organization and responsibilities.

Maintenance activities are also responding to changing expectations as follows:

  • Rapidly growing awareness of the extent to which electrical equipment failure affects safety of plant and personnel and the environment.
  • Growing awareness of the connection between maintenance and product quality.
  • Increasing pressure to achieve high plant availability remaining cost-effective.

The changes are testing attitudes and skills in all branches of industry to the limit. Maintenance people are required to adopt completely new ways of thinking and acting, as the plant engineers and as the plant managers. At the same time, the limitations of maintenance systems are becoming increasingly apparent, no matter how much they are computerized.

In the face of this avalanche of change, the industries are looking for a new approach to the maintenance to avoid the false starts and dead ends which always accompany major upheavals.

Instead they seek a strategic framework which synthesizes the new developments into a coherent pattern, so that they can evaluate them sensibly and apply those likely to be of most value to them and their companies.

Effort is made in this paper to discuss some aspects of new approach.


Failures of electrical equipment

An example of electrical equipment failure

An example of electrical equipment failure (photo credit: bralpowerassociate.blogspot.com)


Failure of any electrical equipment or rather any equipment should be taken up seriously. Detailed analysis of each failure should be carried out, which will help in significant reduction of repeated failures of same nature.

It is true that in spite of carrying out regular maintenance, failure of the equipment cannot be totally eliminated. Failures of different types of electrical equipment are reported by all the industries and some of the failures are quite serious resulting in substantial production losses besides causing consequential damage to the adjoining equipment as well.

For example, when the equipment like surge arrestors operating at extra high voltage fail, they explode like a bomb many a times resulting in scattering of solid porcelain pieces to a larger distance causing damage to the adjoining equipment. Similar situation is also observed during incident of fire in electrical switchboards due to heavy short circuit.

Unless regular equipment maintenance is carried out adopting any of the maintenance systems discussed in succeeding points, unscheduled failure of the equipment would go on resulting into large scale production losses in the industries on one hand and would increase the cost of maintenance on the other hand, as the cost of breakdown maintenance is normally more than that of other types of maintenance.


Breakdown Maintenance Management (BMM)

The heading itself implies simple and straightforward logic – “When a machine breaks down, fix it”. This is a reactive maintenance management technique that waits for machine or equipment failure before any maintenance action is taken; however, it is actually a “no-maintenance” approach of the management.

No expenditure is made on maintenance until a machine or system fails to operate.

Few plants adopt a true run-to-failure management philosophy, as in almost all instances, the industries carry out basic preventive maintenance tasks such as lubrication, monitoring of operating parameters and other machine adjustments.

In this type of maintenance, however, the electrical machines and other plant equipment are neither rebuilt, nor are any major repairs made until the machine fails to operate.

High spare parts inventory cost…

Or high value due to replacement of machine

In absence of anticipated periodic maintenance requirements, the industry that adopting BMM must be able to react immediately to all possible failures within the plant.

This reactive method of management forces the maintenance department to maintain large spare parts inventories that may include spare machines or at least all major components for all the critical equipment in the plant. The alternative is to rely on the equipment vendors that can provide immediate delivery of required spare parts to repair the equipment.

BMM is the most expensive method of maintenance management. The major costs associated with this type of maintenance management are as follows.

High overtime labour costs…

Regular maintenance could potentially avoid fatal failure and burning of transformers

Regular maintenance could potentially avoid fatal failure and burning of transformers


The equipment may breakdown at any damned hour of day or night and hence it may be necessary to retain additional manpower to carry out the maintenance and repairing within least possible time to bring the equipment back into service to reduce the production losses.

The manpower retained beyond normal duty hours would be paid substantial cost towards overtime.


High equipment downtime and high cost of maintenance…

This reactive method of maintenance results into rather high equipment downtime in most of the incidents of breakdown.

Many times, all the spare parts required to set right the breakdown are not available and the vendor is approached to purchase the spares. Even if immediate delivery of required spares is affected, substantial time would always be lost before the equipment is repaired and put back into service.

Moreover, the vendor would charge premiums for expedited delivery, which would substantially increase the costs of spare parts besides higher downtime required to correct machine failures. This happens due to the fact that it is not feasible to maintain all the spare parts for all the machines installed in the plant.


Loss of profit due to partial or total stoppage of production…

Loss of profit due to partial or total stoppage of production

Loss of profit due to partial or total stoppage of production (photo credit: eagnews.org)


This reactive maintenance may be appropriate for low value and non-critical equipment. For costly and critical equipment, it is not desirable to wait till the occurrence of breakdown, as the cost of breakdown is always more to the industries than the cost of preventive maintenance.

The revenue loss due to non-availability of the system would be much more than the cost of the failed equipment.

Therefore, it is more appropriate to identify the defect before failure to plan repair / replacement. Though, the equipment breakdowns cannot be avoided in totality, but incidents can be reduced to great extent with appropriate type of maintenance.

Will be continued… stay in the tune ;)


About Author //

author-pic

Ashok Parikh

Ashok Parikh - Working as Electrical Engineering Consultant located at Vadodara, India providing System Design & Engineering services to various industries, possessing 40 years of experience in diversified industries and consultancy.



10 Comments


  1. awny
    Sep 24, 2014

    How do I download the PDF format of this article and thank you very much Please reply as soon as possible


  2. malik
    Sep 13, 2014

    Sir
    I m working as a technician this is very usefull article for me.
    Dhanyavad.
    Thnk u


  3. Thabo Vilane
    Sep 07, 2014

    Thanks very much Ashok


  4. Edvard
    Sep 04, 2014

    I must say, this is the most concise, but very complete overview of conditon monitoring maintenance of el. equipment. You put it all together in a great way.

    A BIG THANK YOU Ashok!

    Kind regards


  5. Eric Schreiber
    Aug 26, 2014

    I am surprised the article does not make reference to modern predictive algorithms technologies. Condition Based Maintenance is old fashioned and modern computing power has enabled a vast array of effective methods to predict failure.

    …maybe in Part 2?


    • Ashok Parikh
      Sep 05, 2014

      Dear Mr. Eric,

      The objective of article is to supplement efforts put up by the maintenance engineers so that their work would be more fruitful. In case someone wants to use the latest computer based technologies during the course of maintenance activities, it is most welcome. However, it may also be noted that modern technology, when integrated with manual efforts, in-depth observations for condition of equipment, would only provide advantage. To keep the article simple and basic, reference is not made to the other techniques.


  6. Bruce Fairweather
    Aug 25, 2014

    Not only do I perform electrical inspections but also risk management and loss control reviews for other property and liability issues. It is amazing what I find during a survey. Some firms have raised the bar on oversight of all systems dealing with fire protection and life safety schemes. Electrical maintenance is a major component. Others, be it industrial, commercial or municipal have either not received the word or have accepted the higher risk of a catastrophic event as opposed to investing in safety. .


  7. Abdullah Habib Zia
    Aug 25, 2014

    Awesome article.


  8. amin askari
    Aug 25, 2014

    thank you


  9. Rex
    Aug 25, 2014

    This article is very useful for me ,i don’t know about electrical equipment maintenance ,i learned something in this article ,thank you..

    Rex
    from Bizbilla.com

Leave a Comment

Tell us what you're thinking... we care about your opinion!
and oh, not to forget - if you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a free Gravatar!


nine − 2 =

FOLLOW EEP!

Subscribe to Weekly Download Updates:
(free electrical software, spreadsheets and EE guides)

EEP's Android Application
Electrical Engineering Daily Dose
Daily dose of knowledge and news from
Electrical Engineering World
Get
PDF