Menu
Search
What Would Be The Worst Type Of Three Phase Faults (And Why It Happens)
What Would Be The Worst Type Of Three Phase Faults And Why It Happens (photo credit: everreadyelectric.com)

When Three Phase Faults Occur…

In a three phase power system, the type of faults that can occur are classified by the combination of conductors or buses that are faulted together. In addition, faults may be classified as either bolted faults or faults that occur through some impedance such as an arc. Each of the basic types of faults will be described and shown in Figure 1.

It must be noted that in a majority of cases, the fault current calculation required for the selection of interrupting and withstand current capabilities of equipment is the three phase bolted fault with zero impedance.

Let’s go through each of the four three phase faults //

  1. Three phase bolted faults
  2. Bolted line-to-line faults
  3. Line-to-line-to-ground faults
  4. Line-to-ground faults
Designation of short-circuit categories
Figure 1 – Designation of short-circuit categories

1. Three Phase Bolted Faults

A three phase bolted fault describes the condition where the three conductors are physically held together with zero impedance between them, just as if they were bolted together. For a balanced symmetrical system, the fault current magnitude is balanced equally within the three phases.

While this type of fault does not occur frequently, its results are used for protective device selection, because this fault type generally yields the maximum short-circuit current values.

Figure 1(a) provides a graphical representation of a bolted three phase fault.

Three-phase short circuit
Figure 1a – Three-phase short circuit

Go back to three phase faults ↑


2. Bolted Line-To-Line Faults

Bolted line-to-line faults, Figure 1(b), are more common than three phase faults and have fault currents that are approximately 87% of the three phase bolted fault current.

This type of fault is not balanced within the three phases and its fault current is seldom calculated for equipment ratings because it does not provide the maximum fault current magnitude. The line-to-line current can be calculated by multiplying the three phase value by 0.866, when the impedance Z1 = Z2.

Special symmetrical component calculating techniques are not required for this condition.

Bolted line-to-line faults
Figure 1b – Bolted line-to-line faults

Go back to three phase faults ↑


3. Line-To-Line-To-Ground Faults

Line-to-line-to-ground faults, Figure 1(c), are typically line-to-ground faults that have escalated to include a second phase conductor. This is an unbalanced fault. The magnitudes of double line-to-ground fault currents are usually greater than those of line-to-line faults, but are less than those of three phase faults.

Calculation of double line-to-ground fault currents requires the use of symmetrical components analysis. The impedance of the ground return path will affect the result, and should be obtained if possible.

Line-to-line-to-ground faults
Figure 1c – Line-to-line-to-ground faults



Go back to three phase faults ↑


4. Line-To-Ground Faults

Line-to-ground faults, Figure 1(d), are the most common type of faults and are usually the least disturbing to the system. The current in the faulted phase can range from near zero to a value slightly greater than the bolted three phase fault current.

The line-to-ground fault current magnitude is determined by the method in which the system is grounded and the impedance of the ground return path of the fault current.

Calculation of the exact line-to-ground fault current magnitudes requires the special calculating techniques of symmetrical components.

Line-to-ground faults
Figure 1d – Line-to-ground faults

However, close approximations can be made knowing the method of system grounding used. On ungrounded distribution systems, the line-to-ground fault currents are near zero.

Line-to-ground fault current magnitudes in distribution systems with resistance grounded system neutrals can be estimated by dividing the system line-to-neutral system voltage by the total value of the system ground- to-neutral resistance.

Line-to-ground fault current magnitudes in distribution systems with a solidly grounded system will be approximately equal to the three phase fault current magnitudes. Determining line-to-ground fault currents on long cable runs or transmission lines will require detailed ground return path impedance data and detailed calculation techniques.

Go back to three phase faults ↑

Reference // IEEE Recommended Practice for Calculating Short-Circuit Currents in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems

About Author //

author-pic

Edvard Csanyi

Edvard - Electrical engineer, programmer and founder of EEP. Highly specialized for design of LV high power busbar trunking (<6300A) in power substations, buildings and industry fascilities. Designing of LV/MV switchgears.Professional in AutoCAD programming and web-design.Present on

One Comment


  1. Lenny Curcio
    Nov 15, 2016

    Hi,
    Your information has certainly helped my electrical learning curve.
    I’m a Mech. Engineer assessing damages and justifying reimbursement from FEMA for NYC due to Sandy Flooding. Electrical equipment was damaged via faults, but FEMA advised the equipment is above the flood level. What I have tried to explain is that the Submersible Sewage Pumps were compromised when the flood level inundated the splice boxes causing a 3 Phase Fault upon start-up with trailered portable generators. FEMA says there should have been protective devices between the Pump Motors and MCC, which would cause an open. I believe the overcurrent fused these devices as the design and conditions study did not protect for the max fault as it was the least likely to occur. Arc-flash study may have recommended that protective devices protect lower voltage/amperage equipment more prevalent to damage occurrences.
    1. Am I correct and can other components be damaged during a 3 Phase fault past the protective device, and if so;
    2. Can you assist in the proper language (Electrical Engineering) to explain and justify that it could happen?

    Much appreciated,
    Lenny Curcio

Leave a Comment

Tell us what you're thinking... we care about your opinion!


Get PDF