Premium Membership ♕

CYBER WEEK OFFER 💥 Save 20% on PRO Membership Plan and Video Courses with the coupon CYM23 and learn from experienced engineers.

Home / Technical Articles / A case study of 110/10 kV substation with centralized protection, automation and control system

Centralized substation protection and control

Centralized substation protection and control has been attempted in the past based on the available technology. This evolution is now at the intersection of sensing, protection and communication technologies, providing the unique opportunity to develop a more reliable and maintainable CPC system.

A case study of 110/10 kV substation with centralized protection and control
A case study of 110/10 kV substation with centralized protection and control (on photo: Altai closed electrical substation 110/10/6 kV; credit:

This article discusses a software based substation protection, automation, and control system (PACS), iSAS, developed by LYSIS LLC, Russia which is was at that time under trial operation at the 110/10 kV “Olympic” substation in the town of Surgut in northwest Siberia.

The philosophy of iSAS is based on PAC function element implementation as per IEC 61850 logical nodes (LN).

The PACS structure of 110/10 kV Olympic substation in Northwest Siberia, Russia
The PACS structure of 110/10 kV Olympic substation in Northwest Siberia, Russia (click to expand)

The software modules were developed independently of particular hardware and could be placed in dedicated IEDs as well as in one powerful computer. When the software modules are located in the same device they interact with each other through the iSAS software core over its internal mechanisms.

However, when they are distributed among various devices then they use Process and/or Station Bus communication services.

The decision about the allocation of functions depends on particular project requirements and performance of available hardware and resource consumption by software modules. Conformity to the IEC 61850 information model and configuration language (SCL) was one of the main priorities of the project.

Overview of iSAS project

iSAS is implemented in a PAC system for a 110/10 kV substation pilot project for one Russian Distribution System Operator (DSO) – Tumenenergo. The project is completely managed and implemented by iSAS’ software developer – LYSIS LLC.

The project has the following goals:

  1. Search for an optimal system architecture, methods and approaches for iSAS lifecycle management,
  2. Research and analyze system characteristics and behavior under real-life conditions,
  3. Provide technical and economic analysis at all stages of the system lifecycle, as well as comparison with conventional systems with similar functionality,
  4. Conduct a reliability analysis and comparison with a system with conventional architecture,
  5. Quantify the advantages and disadvantages of the PACS system, along with the suitability for the DSO to spread out such experience widely.

The selected 110/10 kV Olympic substation, for the pilot implementation of a centralized digital PAC system, contains two power transformers, two incoming 110 kV overhead power lines and 40 feeders connected to four 10 kV busbars.

The digital software-based PACS implemented in the project has to perform the full functionality of protection, control and metering systems for the entire substation according to regulatory standards and customer’s requirements.

According to the contract, the project had 5 phases:

  1. Design,
  2. Procurement, installation and testing,
  3. Trial operation of the system for one year,
  4. Analysis of regulators requirements, rules, and standards, and proposing amendments in these documents for homologation of software-based PAC systems in the Russian market, and
  5. Certification of measuring method for process bus-based systems with separate measuring (process interfacing devices, PID) and calculation (IEDs) parts.

At that time, LYSYS LLC has completed the design, procurement, installation and testing phases and the system has been put in trial operation. Phases 4 and 5 were completed by the end of 2015.

1. Protection subsystem

The single line diagram of the substation is shown in Figure 1.

Single line diagram of 110 kV Olympic substation
Figure 1 – Single line diagram of 110 kV Olympic substation (click to expand SLD)

Protection and related automatics of the two 110 kV power lines include the following functions:

  • Line Differential Protection(87L) include an equipment at the remote terminal,
  • Three stages of Distance Protection (21P),
  • Four stages of Ground (Earth) Overcurrent Protection (51N),
  • Instantaneous Phase-to-phase Overcurrent Protection (50P),
  • Automatic Reclosing (79), and
  • Breaker Failure Protection (50BF).

110 kV busbars are protected by Busbar Differential Protection (87B) function.

110/10 kV Transformer protection and automatics contains following functions:

  • Transformer Differential Protection (87T),
  • Transformer Overload Protection (51),
  • HV-side Time Overcurrent Protection (51P),
  • LV-side Time Overcurrent Protection (51P), and
  • Automated Voltage Regulator.

10 kV side of transformers connected bus-bars and Feeders are equipped with:

  • Two stages Phase-to-phase Time Overcurrent Protection (51P),
  • Breaker Failure Protection (50BF),
  • Interlocking Overcurrent Busbar Protection,
  • Automatic Closing of Bus-tie Breaker,
  • Under Frequency Load Shedding, and
  • Under Frequency Load Restoration.

2. Control subsystem

The control subsystem is associated with operator activity. It is aimed at primary equipment and process monitoring and control. The system includes following functions and possibilities:

  • Control and state monitoring of all motorized switching apparatus, such as disconnectors, earth switches and circuit breakers,
  • Providing one and two-step (select before operate) control models,
  • Automatically performing predefined sequences of operational actions,
  • Gathering of analog and discrete data of primary equipment and process parameters and their visual representation at HMIs,
  • Access, retrieval and visual representation of archived data including alarm and event lists,
  • Bay level and substation level interlocking,
  • Transformer tap changer manual control, and
  • Remote control of system parameters like settings of protection and control algorithms.

All the above control functions are accessible to operator via local HMIs as well through local and remote SCADA using the virtual telecontrol gateway provided by iSAS software.

3. Revenue Metering System

The revenue metering system was implemented in compliance with energy market rules and contains following functionalities:

  • Active Energy and Power metering,
  • Reactive Energy and Power metering,
  • Energy and power are measured in both forward and reverse directions,
  • Storing energy and power in 30 minute profiles for up to 150 days, and
  • Integration of the system into existing DSO-scale metering and billing system.

4. Monitoring and Recording Subsystem

The monitoring and recording subsystem is comprised of two components – alarm and event management (AEM) and transient recording. AEM allows detection of the alarming state of monitored parameters and forms a record in alarm and event lists and archives.

Alarming state detection is based on a predefined configuration that includes logical scheme and activation conditions.

For example, the open position of circuit breaker will generate alarm if it is not the result of operator action. It is necessary to monitor the signal that has led to opening of switchgear to relate the cause of circuit breaker open state. Possible cases are depicted as logical expression that defines whether to alarm for status of an event.

Some custom LNs were developed to model AEM functions as per IEC 61850. The alarm and event messages are logged and accessed by standard IEC 61850 Log service.

Fault recorder function is able to register currents, voltages, protection start and trip signals, primary equipment states and operational parameters etc. It is possible to register as raw instantaneous values as well as derived calculated parameters like RMS values. Performance and resolution of recording function is enough for recording transient processes like short circuits at monitored equipment.

Also, IEC 61850- 9-2 LE Sampled Values data streams (80 samples/cycle and 256 samples/cycle) are recorded. The function provides access to records in COMTRADE format as per IEC 60255-24:2013/IEEE Std. C37.111-2013. The recorder covers all control points available by GOOSE and Sampled Values at the substation.

Moreover, the COMTRADE format was expanded to allow storage of quality information of IEC 61850 Data Attributes.

5. Fault Locator Function

This function detects fault locations on both 110 kV power lines. Single-ended measurements are used with a target error of less than 5% of line length.

6. Power Quality Monitoring Function

Power quality monitoring and analysis are harmonized with international standards IEC 61000-4-30 and IEC 61000- 4-7, although there are some differences. Power quality monitoring is done at all the four busbars of the 10 kV system to comply with the project requirements.

The PAC system provides following parameters:

  • Frequency deviation,
  • Positive and negative voltage deviations,
  • Steady-state voltage deviation,
  • Voltage dips, Overvoltage and Voltage interruptions,
  • Current and voltage harmonics up to 50th order,
  • Subgroup total harmonic distortion (up to 50th order) for voltage and current,
  • Group inter-harmonic distortion (up to 50th order) for voltage and current,
  • Centered subgroup total inter-harmonic distortion (up to 50th order) for voltage and current,
  • RMS harmonic components (up to 50th order) for current and voltage,
  • RMS harmonic subgroup (up to 50th order) for current and voltage,
  • RMS interharmonic group (up to 50th order) for current and voltage,
  • RMS interharmonic centered subgroup (up to 50th order) for current and voltage,
  • Positive-, negative- and zero-sequence voltages,
  • Zero sequence voltage unbalance factor,
  • Negative-sequence voltage unbalance factor, and
  • Sequence power

Software-based PAC System Architecture

The core of the designed PACS is the iSAS software suite that allows freedom to decide where and how to place a particular function. The iSAS is not dependent on hardware used and provides freedom to allocate function modules among available computation platforms.

Therefore, the logical structure of the system is independent of its physical implementation and both are harmonized by their own rules considering their own requirements.

Optimization research was performed to define the most suitable and effective system physical structure for this particular substation. An optimization procedure was used to gradually approach the desired values of system’s quality metrics, starting from the simplest and cheapest structure that provides system operability in required functionality using an iterative approach.

The simplest system means:

  1. No redundancy,
  2. Maximum functions concentration in single hardware,
  3. No periodical checking and testing, and
  4. No diagnostic.

At each next step of the optimization algorithm, one improvement measure is added. The improvement measure is chosen from the list that was ranked by cost efficiency. At the start, the measures with highest efficiency rating are used. PAC functions availability and maximum affordable repairing rate was applied as system’s quality metrics. Normative values of system metrics were taken from the conventional PAC system of the same substation.

The customer’s requirements, such as placing revenue metering and PQ functionality into a dedicated server with its separate cabinet, were taken into consideration. Optimization studies resulted in the system structure shown in Figure 1 above.

Reference // Centralized Substation Protection and Control – IEEE PES / Power System Relaying Committee (Report of Working Group K15 of the Substation Protection Subcommittee)

Premium Membership

Get access to premium HV/MV/LV technical articles, electrical engineering guides, research studies and much more! It helps you to shape up your technical skills in your everyday life as an electrical engineer.
More Information

Edvard Csanyi

Electrical engineer, programmer and founder of EEP. Highly specialized for design of LV/MV switchgears and LV high power busbar trunking (<6300A) in power substations, commercial buildings and industry facilities. Professional in AutoCAD programming.

Leave a Comment

Tell us what you're thinking. We care about your opinion! Please keep in mind that comments are moderated and rel="nofollow" is in use. So, please do not use a spammy keyword or a domain as your name, or it will be deleted. Let's have a professional and meaningful conversation instead. Thanks for dropping by!

sixty three  −  fifty six  =  

Learn How to Design Power Systems

Learn to design LV/MV/HV power systems through professional video courses. Lifetime access. Enjoy learning!

Subscribe to Weekly Newsletter

Subscribe to our Weekly Digest newsletter and receive free updates on new technical articles, video courses and guides (PDF).
EEP Academy Courses - A hand crafted cutting-edge electrical engineering knowledge