Service factor for motors
When a motor is expected to operate in unfavorable conditions such as:
- Intermittent overloading
- Higher ambient temperatures
- A restricted temperature rise as for a spinning mill,
- A refinery or a hazardous area
- Frequent starts, stops and reverses or any such conditions during operation
Continued from 3rd part of article – Basics of 3-phase Induction Motor (part 3)
And when it is not possible to accurately define their likely occurrences or magnitudes, it becomes desirable for the motor to have some in-built reserve capacity. To account for this, a factor, known as the ‘service factor’, is considered when selecting the size of the motor. Service factor’ in the range of 10-15% is considered adequate by practicing engineers. With this service factor, no more derating would normally be necessary.
Service factor is a multiplier that is applied to the motor’s normal horsepower rating to indicate an increase in power output (or overload capacity) that the motor is capable of providing under certain conditions some of which are mentioned above.
Any service factor greater than one 1.0 must be indicated on motor nameplate; in some case the running current at service factor loading is also indicated on the nameplate as service factor amperes or SFA.
In the above description, it’s the “certain conditions” where problems may occur. The service factor is not intended as a general increase in the motor horsepower rating. In most cases, a 10 kW motor with 1.15 service factor should not be treated as an 11.5 kW motor and it is not considered acceptable for application to a pump or fan with this service factor to operate continuously at 11 kW.
Many facilities may experience occasional periods of low voltage during peak load periods. Under this condition a motor operating within its service factor rating may experience an unacceptable increase in current and temperature. The motor is permitted under the standard to operate at a 10 degrees C higher winding temperature rise under service factor load than under its normal rated load. As a rule of thumb life expectancy is halved for each 10 degree increase in operating temperature.
Thus continuous operation at service factor load can be expected to a higher rate motor failure due to insulation breakdown. The increased load may also reduce bearing life.
- Relying on the service factor of motor under continuous duty operations would be unwise in most cases.
- The appropriate use of this rating is to handle short term or occasional overloads.
- It is suitable only where supply voltage is highly stable as in case of industrial premises having self generation units.
- Motor life expectancy is not a concern.
Electrical protections required for 3 Phase induction motor
The conditions for the protection required in a motor can be divided into two broad categories:
- Imposed external conditions
- Internal Faults.
The former category includes unbalanced supply voltages, Under Voltage, over voltage, under frequency, over frequency, single phasing and reverse phase conditions. The latter category includes the bearing failures, Internal Shunt faults, which are commonly earth faults and Over loads.
The Protection applied to a particular machine depends on its size and the nature of load to which it is connected.
Thermal Image Protection with Pre-Alarm
The majority of the winding failures are either directly or Indirectly caused by over loading.(either prolonged or cyclic),operation on unbalanced supply or single phasing which all leads to the deterioration of the insulation until the electrical fault occurs in the winding.
All motors will have a thermal with stand curves which indicates the thermal withstand time at various over load currents. The Heating of the machine is because of the thermal current which can be derived from the positive and negative sequence components of the Motor current as follows.
Ith = √ (Id2 + 3Is2 )
Ith = Thermal Current which causes the heating
Id = Positive Sequence Component of the Input Current
Is = Negative sequence Component of the Input Current.
It can be seen that the negative sequence plays proportionately more than positive sequence current in the heating of the machine. The relay should computes the positive and negative sequence components and calculate the thermal current. The ideal relay should calculate sequence component on the basis of vector calculation.
In most of the motor protection relay, Motor Full load current can be set from 10% to 150% of the rated current and the time Constant is selectable from 1 to 60 minutes depending on the motor Characteristics. Pre heating alarm can be set from 50% to 110% of the thermal condition of the machine. This will help to avoid the tripping of the motor in a continuously processing industry.
There is a Restart inhibition Temperature level which ensures the next starting of the machine after the Motor cooled down to the safe temperature level.
Locked Rotor Protection
The ideal relay should provide protection against both starting and running locked rotor condition. In most of the relays the setting is selectable from 100% to 500% of the motor full load current. The trip time delay is selectable from 1 to 120 seconds. Additionally the relay can accept a speed switch contact from the field to detect the starting locked rotor condition.
Current Unbalance Protection
The relay is provided with a Negative sequence current element will provide protection of the motor from Current Unbalance due to voltage Unbalance, Single phasing and Phase reversals. The negative sequence level is settable from 10% to 80% of motor full load current. The trip time characteristics are inverse time characteristics.
Repeat Start Protection
If the number starts exceeded the set value, the relay inhibits the next start for a set time. This time is called restart inhibition time, which is selectable from 1 to 60 minutes.
Over Current Protection
This protection element will provide short circuit protection in the motor feeder. The trip time delay can be set as either instantaneous or time delayed. Ideal motor protection element is provided with the above element in which the pickup range is selectable from 1 to 5 times Ist. The delay is selectable from 0.05 to 1 second. It is to be noted that if the motor is provided with vacuum contactor in which the contactor cannot handle the short circuit current, this over current element need to be disabled.
In such cases fuses provided in the power circuit will provide the short circuit protection.
No load running
This element provides the protection against no load running of motors. The pickup level is selectable from 0.15 to 1Im and the trip time delay is adjustable.
This element is disabled if the current is below 0.1 Im.
Earth fault Protection
This protection provides the isolation of motors incase of earth faults. This element can be connected in residual connection or by using a CBCT. Ideal motor protection relay is provided with an earth fault pick up setting of 2% to 100% and a delay setting of 0.05secs to 5secs. Third harmonic filter should be checked to avoid any mal operation because of unbalanced currents.
It is to be noted that, in case of residual connection, if the earth fault element is provided with instantaneous protection, the earth fault element may cause unwanted operation during the starting of the motor. This is because of the unequal saturation characteristics of the CTs provided in the system. To avoid the above problem a stabilizing resistor need to be provided in the earth fault circuit.
The value of stabilizing resistor can be calculated as below:
R > Ist ( R2+Rw ) x I0
Ist = Motor starting current (at secondary of CT’s)
I0 = Set trip level of E/F element (at secondary. of CT’s)
R2 = Resistance of CT sec. Winding
Rw = Resistance of wire loop between CT and relay
Apart from the above protections, having RTD and BTD input is optional feature. If RTD input is required than a PT100 device which is installed near the winding will increase its resistance when the temperature rises. It is to be noted that the PT100 device need to be calibrated above 1.5K ohm corresponding to the abnormal temperature.
1. NEMA MG-1.
2. Industrial Power Engineering and Application Hand Book by K C Agarwaal.
3. Industrial Power System Hand Book by Shoaib Khan.
4. Theory and Calculation of Alternating Current Phenomena by Charles Proteus Steinmetz
5. Motor protection relay (MM30) manual from L&T