Premium Membership ♕

CYBER MONDAY OFFER 💥 Save 20% on PRO Membership Plan and Video Courses with the coupon CYM23 and learn from experienced engineers.

Home / Technical Articles / Why to automate power substation? What do you get?

Substation automation functions

Substation automation involves the deployment of substation and feeder operating functions and applications ranging from SCADA and alarm processing, to integrated volt-var control in order to optimize the management of capital assets and enhance operation and maintenance efficiencies with minimal human intervention.

Why to automate power substation? What do you get?
Why to automate power substation? What do you get? - Application functions and applications of a substation automation and protection (on photo: 115kV control and protection panel)

It is evident that substation automation is implemented to reduce human intervention and to improve the operating efficiency of the system.

Optimization of assets and reduction of operating costs in the long run are added advantages of the substation automation.

Distribution SCADA will have the basic functions like monitoring and control, report generation, and historical data storage and several functions for special application in the substation automation scheme.

The following sections will elaborate on the application functions.

  1. Integrated protection functions: Traditional approach and IED-based approach
  2. Automation functions:
    1. Intelligent bus failover and automatic load restoration
    2. Supply line sectionalizing
      1. How sectionalizers work?
    3. Adaptive relaying
    4. Equipment condition monitoring (ECM)
  3. Enterprise-level application functions:
    1. Disturbance analysis
    2. Intelligent alarm processing
    3. Power quality monitoring
    4. Real-time equipment monitoring

1. Integrated protection functions: Traditional approach and IED-based approach

In the traditional approach, the relays had hardwired inputs from the instrument transformers, and from the relays, hardwires carried the trip signals to the circuit breakers, as shown in Figure 1.

Protection via hard wiring and (b) protection via LAN
Figure 1 – Protection via hard wiring and (b) protection via LAN

In the IED-based modern approach, the information from instrument transformers will reach the relay IEDs via LAN, the relays exchange information via LAN, and with the process bus becoming a reality, the circuit breakers will receive a trip signals via a generic object-oriented substation event (GOOSE) message traveling in the process bus, as illustrated in Figure 1b.

In case of a breaker failure, in the traditional protection wiring scheme, the hardwiring will carry the trip signal to the backup protection scheme, as shown in Figure 2a.

On the other hand, in a modern protection scheme, the backup protection is initiated via LAN as given in Figure 2b, which reduces the wiring tremendously and also will utilize alternate pathways.

(a) Protection via hard wiring and (b) protection via GOOSE messaging using LANs.
Figure 2 – (a) Protection via hard wiring and (b) protection via GOOSE messaging using LANs.

Protection functions like automatic reclosing and bus differential schemes can be implemented, and breaker failure can be dealt with effectively.

The benefit lies in the fact that separate protection relays can be avoided, and thus performance improvement and reliability enhancement are achieved.

Go back to contents ↑

2. Automation functions

The substation automation application functions include intelligent bus failover, automatic load restoration, adaptive relaying, and equipment condition monitoring, which are explained in the following sections.

2.1 Intelligent bus failover and automatic load restoration

This scheme is generally used in a distribution substation where there are two transformers and a normally open bus tie breaker.

When a transformer in a substation fails, the simple bus failover scheme transfers the load to the healthy transformer in the substation, which may overload the healthy transformer and lead to another failure.

Hence, the bus failover schemes have been disabled in some cases.

The substation firm capacity is limited by the load (overload) that can be carried by the healthy transformer. However, in an intelligent bus failover scheme, the substation automation system will ensure that the healthy transformer is not overloaded.

This can be done by load shedding one or a few of the outgoing feeders temporarily. These feeders can be supplied from an adjacent substation by closing a tie switch, and the disruption in load can be minimized.

The beneft of this scheme is primarily improvement in reliability as the transfer of load is done as quickly as possible. Outage duration can be reduced from 30 min to 1 min. The scheme also allows better equipment utilization.

“Intelligent” load transfer will allow higher loading under normal conditions, as the substation firm capacity is limited to the amount of load that can be carried following a single contingency, like a transformer failure.

Intelligent bus failover demonstration
Figure 3 – Intelligent bus failover demonstration

Figure 3 shows the fault on transformer B. Circuit breakers 1 and 2 will trip and isolate transformer B, and circuit breaker 3 will be closed to transfer the load on to transformer A, which will get overloaded and may have to shed load by opening circuit breaker 4.

However, the load can be transferred subsequently by connecting the line to the adjacent substation automatically by closing breaker 5.

Go back to contents ↑

2.2 Supply line sectionalizing

The distribution substations are often tapped off a supply line without high side breaker protection. This creates a problem, and considerable load may be out of service until the field crew arrives.

The objectives of the scheme are to identify the faulted section of supply line, isolate the faulted section, and restore supply to the substations fed off the unfaulted section of the supply line.

The benefit is that improvement in reliability as the service to substations that are without power can be restored as quickly as possible. The outage duration is reduced from 30 to 1 or 2 min.

Go back to contents ↑

How sectionalizers work?

Around 80% of the faults in the medium-voltage overhead lines are of transient nature and thus often self-clearing type. To restore the supply for the faulty feeder after line tripping, different autoreclosing schemes are employed.

In case the feeder is affected by a non-self-clearing type of fault, a lot of customers are affected by a long supply break after several unsuccessful autoreclosing attempts. If the actual fault is close to the end of the feeder, the customers closer to the substation could be still supplied if the faulty section of the feeder could be isolated.

For such cases, the optimally located automated sectionalizers can be the answer.

When the sectionalizer is equipped with a motor-operating mechanism, measuring transformers (or sensors) and local control and supervising features, the sectionalizer becomes a so called automated sectionalizer. With an automated sectionalizer, it is possible to build discriminative fault isolation schemes. The automated sectionalizer works in coordination with up-stream switching devices, utilizing the de-energized periods during the autoreclosing scheme to operate and isolate faulty sections.

The automated sectionalizer counts the reclosing attempts made by the upstream device, like reclosing breaker at the upstream substation, and after a pre-selected number of attempts, it automatically opens during the de-energized period of the autoreclosing sequence.

Following diagram shows a simple radial feeder case of utilizing the functionality of an automated sectionalizer together with the circuit breaker’s autoreclosing scheme for discriminative fault isolation.

An example of utilizing sectionalizers for discriminative fault isolation in radial feeder application
Figure 4 – An example of utilizing sectionalizers for discriminative fault isolation in radial feeder application

When the fault appears on the overhead line section beyond the sectionalizer, the protective relaying at the supplying substation and at the sectionalizer recognizes the case.

The protective relaying at the substation starts the autoreclosing sequence by tripping the circuit breaker in time of T1. The sectionalizer acknowledges this action. After a preset time delay (T2), the circuit breaker recloses. Since the fault has not been cleared, the circuit breaker trips again after a preset time delay of T3. The sectionalizer commences its opening cycle during the feeder’s de-energized period of T4.

The actual sectionalizer opening command is issued after a preset time delay of T5.

After the time delay of T4 of the autoreclosing scheme has elapsed, the sectionalizer is fully open and the circuit breaker recloses, energizing the healthy sections of the feeder.

Go back to contents ↑

2.3 Adaptive relaying

This is very important. Adaptive relaying is the process of automatically altering the settings of protective relay IEDs based on the system conditions.

This can be of much help to an operator when there is a crisis in the system, with main lines and generators tripping.

The special protection function of the substation automation system can play a role by altering the settings of some of the relay IEDs.

As an example, in the event of tripping of a critical generator, a line may get heavily loaded due to the diversion of power from other sources. Under normal circumstances, this will lead to the tripping of this line which may escalate to an emergency situation. The master at the control center will detect the trip and can inform the corresponding SA system of the event.

The SA system can switch the appropriate relays to the new settings to carry the required power until the crisis is over and then can switch back to the original settings.

Go back to contents ↑

2.4 Equipment condition monitoring (ECM)

Many electric utilities have employed ECM to maintain electric equipment in top operating condition while minimizing the number of interruptions.

With ECM, equipment-operating parameters are automatically tracked to detect the emergence of various abnormal operating conditions, using specialized sensors and diagnostic tools. This allows substation operations personnel to take timely action when needed to improve reliability and extend equipment life.

This approach is applied most frequently to substation transformers and high-voltage electric supply circuit breakers to minimize the maintenance costs of these devices, by eliminating the time-based routine testing and thus saving significant labor and material cost.

The number of catastrophic failures is reduced by reducing the repair cost and avoiding forced outages. Dynamic equipment rating is feasible by which more capacity can be squeezed out of the existing equipment, thus improving the availability.

The life of the equipment is thus extended, and even a year or two extension can produce significant savings.

The ECM monitoring devices include:

  1. Dissolved gas in oil monitoring samples
  2. Moisture detectors
  3. Load tap changer monitors
  4. Partial discharge of acoustic monitors
  5. Bushing monitors
  6. Circuit break monitors (GIS and OCB)
  7. Battery monitors
  8. Expert system analyzers

ECM is an added advantage of substation automation.

Go back to contents ↑

3. Enterprise-level application functions

Once the substation is automated, there are many application functions that can be implemented at the enterprise level. The final level indicates the utility enterprise–related implementations in Table 1 below.

Utility Enterprise
Level IIISubstation Automation functions
Level IIIED Integration
Level IIED Implementation
Power system equipment (transformers, breakers, etc.)

First there is the power system equipment such as transformers, circuit breakers, and intelligent instrument transformers and sensors. The first level is IED implementation where different IEDs are installed in the substation.

The second level is IED integration, utilizing the two-way communications of the IED. IEDs from different vendors and with different functionalities have to be integrated to form a cohesive protection, monitoring, and control system, which also performs a number of other functions like waveform recording and metering.

Once the IEDs are integrated, a number of substation automation applications, the third level, can be run to effectively monitor and control the substation and associated feeder and customer automation functions in the power system.

Last, there is the utility enterprise where the integration of different control centers can be performed and utility-wide data sharing and applications can be run.

3.1 Disturbance analysis

Disturbance analysis is an added advantage when IEDs are implemented, as they have inherent capabilities to record the fault waveform, and also the facility to time stamp the measured operational data.

These values can be used to recreate a disturbance sequence as the time stamping to the level of milliseconds or less will help the operator and other personnel in the utility to assess the situation and take corrective action for the next disturbance.

Substation disturbance analyser desktop-based user interface
Figure 6 – Substation disturbance analyser desktop-based user interface

For example, in case of an islanding of a section of the power system, the faults, line tripping, overloading and underloading, and tripping of generators may happen in quick succession. After the islanding the utility personnel must assess the situation and determine the correct sequence of events.

Time stamping of events, analog, or status changes immensely helps the utility to recreate an event and do a thorough analysis of the situations that led to the islanding. The waveforms captured can be used by the maintenance and protection departments to assess the severity of the damage and take corrective action.

Visualization and user interface can be implemented as client-side application executing visualization application or user interface on client computers (Figure 6).

Direct notifications to users and reports customized and formatted for particular user groups should be done using all the available technology means. Additional “intelligence” may be incorporated into reports disseminated based on event priorities and user category.

Go back to contents ↑

3.2 Intelligent alarm processing

Intelligent alarm processing is of utmost importance in a control room to help the operator from getting confused by the battery of alarms triggered by an event.

The screen of substation SCADA showing alarms and events
Figure 5 – The screen of substation SCADA showing alarms and events (photo credit: GeniSYS LLC)

Go back to contents ↑

3.3 Power quality monitoring

Power quality is an important factor in today’s power system operation scenario for two reasons. The quality of power deteriorates due to the influx of new power electronic devices which flood the system with harmonics and ripples.

But quality power is a must for many devices to operate optimally, and a large number of manufacturing facilities require quality power for precision manufacturing.

The SA system with the IEDs implemented and integrated can help in the power quality monitoring by reporting the harmonic content in the voltage waveform and the total harmonic distortion and can also send the oscillographic information to the monitoring center for assessment.

Necessary corrective action can be taken and the power quality can be maintained by the utility.

Go back to contents ↑

3.4 Real-time equipment monitoring

Real-time equipment monitoring is an offshoot of the equipment condition monitoring discussed earlier. Traditionally, power system equipment is loaded to the rated capacity under normal conditions, whereas if the equipment is condition monitored, the loading can be based on actual conditions, rather than on conservative assumptions.

As an example, a transformer detected with a “hot spot” will always be loaded to a much lower value, due to the fear of a catastrophe. However, in a condition monitoring environment, the transformer can be loaded to a higher value by monitoring the true winding hot spot temperature.

The loadability can be derived, and it is reported that 5% to 10% additional loading can be achieved by this activity. Hence, the utility can squeeze more capacity out of the existing equipment and delay investment in new equipment.

Go back to contents ↑

References //

  1. Power System Scada and Smart Grids by Mini S. Thomas and John D. McDonald (Purchase hardcopy from Amazon)
  2. Distribution Automation Handbook by ABB
  3. Automated Fault and Disturbance Analysis: Understanding the Configuration Challenge by M. Kezunovic, Fellow, IEEE, S. Sternfeld, M. Datta-Barua, Member, IEEE, D. Maragal, Member, IEEE, and T. Popovic, Senior Member, IEEE

Premium Membership

Get access to premium HV/MV/LV technical articles, electrical engineering guides, research studies and much more! It helps you to shape up your technical skills in your everyday life as an electrical engineer.
More Information

Edvard Csanyi

Electrical engineer, programmer and founder of EEP. Highly specialized for design of LV/MV switchgears and LV high power busbar trunking (<6300A) in power substations, commercial buildings and industry facilities. Professional in AutoCAD programming.

One Comment

  1. Philip Fadehan
    Oct 16, 2020

    updated insight into and technical Information about, Optimizing HV and LV grid functionality, Distribution Automation, SCADA, Advanced Metering Systems for Network Optimization etc..

Leave a Comment

Tell us what you're thinking. We care about your opinion! Please keep in mind that comments are moderated and rel="nofollow" is in use. So, please do not use a spammy keyword or a domain as your name, or it will be deleted. Let's have a professional and meaningful conversation instead. Thanks for dropping by!

six  +    =  10

Learn How to Design Power Systems

Learn to design LV/MV/HV power systems through professional video courses. Lifetime access. Enjoy learning!

Subscribe to Weekly Newsletter

Subscribe to our Weekly Digest newsletter and receive free updates on new technical articles, video courses and guides (PDF).
EEP Academy Courses - A hand crafted cutting-edge electrical engineering knowledge